oooh shiny – first impressions of Windows 10

You know those clickbait sites that tell you how much of your life you’ve spent asleep or in the lavatory? Well, I’ve been working in hi tech for more than twenty years and I feel I have spent most of that time upgrading Microsoft Windows.

My first role on a technical writing team was being the very junior person who gets all the dull jobs. One of mine was running the upgrade from Windows for Workgroups 3.1 to Windows for Workgroups 3.11 on a dozen desktop PCs. (They sure knew how to name their releases back in those days.) About a year or so later along came Windows 95, and we all thought the future had finally arrived. Those were the days. So when it comes to upgrading Windows, it’s all a bit “been there, done that, lost the t-shirt ages ago” for me. Could Windows 10 impress me?

The first thing that did impress me was the price. Windows 10 is available free of charge to anyone with Windows 7 or Windows 8 for at least the next 12 months. That sounds innovative, except when you remember it’s what Apple have been doing for ages.

There have been a lot of positive reviews about the new interface, and this one in the UK magazine PC Advisor is typical. The interface is certainly modern, and clean, and it combines characteristics of both Windows 7, which was an evolution of the older familiar Windows we’ve known for a long time (a very long time in my case), and the Windows-phone style tile-based interface used in Windows 8 and 8.1. People who didn’t like the Windows 8 design will be pleased to see that the Start menu is back – even though it’s full of those annoying tiles.

Windows 10 doesn’t seem to refer to “programs” any more, only to “apps”. To me it seems that Windows 10 is simply using the more fashionable term, and I don’t know whether it’s even worth discussing whether there are technology differences between apps and programs any more. OK, I’m an old fogey, I know.

Microsoft has proudly asserted that Windows 10 will be available for all platforms – PCs, tablets and phones – so that users will have a seamless experience. That sounds very nice, but it relies on a number of assumptions. One is that you are happy to store all your important files in the cloud, specifically Microsoft’s own One Drive. My personal experience with One Drive has been far from positive. The next assumption is that all your devices are constantly on, and constantly connected to the internet. And they also assume that you are, by default, happy to share everything with everyone, particularly with advertisers, and you’ll just love getting recommendations about what to buy, where to eat, and what to listen to based on what you bought, ate or listened to recently. If that doesn’t exactly describe you – for example, if you actually use a computing device to do your work, rather than just to share things with other people – you’ll need to change a lot of Windows 10’s default settings.

The range of activities that Microsoft Windows 10 is monitoring is very wide, so you may want to read some advice on how to make it monitor less (“spying” is such a loaded term, isn’t it?). Security expert Graham Cluley has also pointed out that Windows 10 is very keen on sharing your wifi network with your friends, and their friends, and their friends too, so you might want to stop that from happening, though it’s not easy to do.

Another thing to be aware of is that with Windows 10 updates are always on. In contrast to previous versions of Windows, you can’t choose not to have automatic updates. That does mean you’ll always have the latest security and operating system patches which is good, but it also means you can’t control when those patches are downloaded and installed, which may cause some problems. It’s all getting a bit too Orwellian for my taste, to be honest.

How I ran my update

I ran my experimental installation of Windows 10 on an older laptop that had been cosmetically repaired (new screen, new keyboard, webcam broken beyond repair). It was running 64-bit Windows 7 Home Premium with SP1, with a Celeron 2.00GHz processor and 3GB RAM. This was within the range of machines that could be upgraded, but definitely towards the low end of that range.

If you are running an upgradeable version of Windows, Microsoft has been encouraging you to register for the free Windows 10 upgrade and wait your turn, but if you are impatient like me you can download the upgrade yourself. I found my way to which is a page intended for network administrators, so what you are downloading is a Media Creation Tool.

The download offered two options – directly upgrading your PC or creating an installation ‘disc’ (on a DVD or a USB stick). I chose the direct upgrade first time, which failed, and the USB option the second time, which was successful. You would need a USB stick with at least 6GB capacity. The download process also warns you that you may need your Windows Product Key, which is often found on a sticker on the back of your laptop. I do have the original sticker with the Key on my laptop, but in practice I wasn’t asked for it. The download took about an hour, during which time you can still use your PC, and then the installation took about 2.5 hours. The first installation looked OK, but the start menu and the taskbar didn’t respond to any mouse clicks at all. Luckily I had chosen to preserve my “files and apps” so I could launch a browser from the desktop and start again.

You should also be aware that Windows 10 doesn’t like local users, and expects you to have a registered Microsoft account to log in to a Windows 10 PC.


Windows 10 is bright and shiny and if you liked Windows 8 you’ll love it. It’s also inevitable, and eventually everyone will have it and get used to it – even with its dodgy use of terminology, and it’s over-zealous tracking of your every move. I can’t see any real reason to rush ahead and upgrade for yourself rather than waiting your turn for an automatic upgrade, unless like me your idea of how to spend a “fun” few hours on a Sunday afternoon is a little bit warped!

You should however be aware of just how intrusive it’s likely to be, and if like me your answer to questions about how much personalised advertising you’d like to have is “as little as possible, thank you” you’ll have fun finding and switching off all of its default settings. We’ll have to wait and see how stable it is and how mandatory automatic updating works – a week after launch the first patch has already been released – but don’t worry about downloading it, you’ll get it automatically.

This entry was posted in miscellaneous, technology. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.